Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Don Harris, By and Through His Mother, Lisa Jorgensen, Individually and On Behalf of A Class v. Julie Hamos

December 26, 2012

DON HARRIS, BY AND THROUGH HIS MOTHER, LISA JORGENSEN, INDIVIDUALLY AND ON BEHALF OF A CLASS, PLAINTIFF,
v.
JULIE HAMOS, IN HER OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS DIRECTOR OF THE ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF HEALTHCARE AND FAMILY SERVICES, DEFENDANT.



The opinion of the court was delivered by: Judge James B. Zagel

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

Plaintiff Don Harris, by and through his mother, Lisa Jorgensen, has brought this action individually and on behalf of a class against Defendant Julie Hamos in her official capacity as Director of the Illinois Department of Healthcare and Family Services. Plaintiff seeks declaratory and injunctive relief, alleging, inter alia, violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act ("ADA"), and the Rehabilitation Act ("RA"). Defendant now moves to dismiss for failure to state a claim, pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 12(b)(6). For the following reasons, Defendant's motion is denied.

BACKGROUND

Don Harris is a medically fragile disabled person who currently receives funding from Defendant for approximately 84 hours per week of private-duty nursing care. Don, who turned 21 last September, had been receiving this treatment through a program called Early Periodic Screening, Diagnosis, and Treatment ("EPSDT"). EPSDT is a program that state Medicaid plans are required by the federal government to include. Under this program, the state must provide any service that is listed in Section 1905(a) of the Social Security Act that is medically necessary to individuals under the age of 21.*fn1

Don has been receiving this care at home by virtue of another Medicaid program, a waiver program for Medically Fragile Technology Dependent Children ("MFTDC"). Under this program, Illinois pays for home-based care for children under the age of 21 who have exceptional medical needs. The Home Services Program ("HSP") is a similar waiver program that services adults. Both programs essentially enable care recipients to receive their care at home, so long as they would otherwise be entitled to the care in an institutional setting, and the net effect of the change in setting is cost neutral.

Don suffers from a genetic disorder called adrenoleukodystrophy, diagnosed when he was a fairly normal four-year-old. He is now severely developmentally disabled and suffers from adrenal insufficiency, seizures, and spastic quadriplegia. Don is blind and non-verbal, and he is completely dependent on others for accomplishing basic bodily functions. He has a gastrostomy tube, weighs approximately 50 pounds, and suffers from severe scoliosis.

In addition to requiring near constant care to aid in basic bodily functions, Don also requires constant care to monitor seizure activity and assess potential signs and symptoms of infections. The disorder from which Don suffers interferes with the body's usual defenses to infections. As a consequence, he does not display the typical signs one sees when a person's body is fighting off infection -- for example, a fever. Careful scrutiny is thus required to watch for subtle, seemingly innocuous signals from Don (for example, slight reddening of the face, or more rapid eye movement than usual) that he is in discomfort and that his body may have encountered some sort of infection. Failure to promptly detect such an infection would almost certainly be fatal.

An evidentiary hearing was held on November 21, 2012 that included testimony from Dr. James H. Tonsgard a specialist who has cared for Don since he was a child. The foregoing account of Don's condition was uncontradicted at the hearing. Dr. Tonsgard testified that Don's survival depended upon him receiving the near constant care he had been receiving from private-duty nurses and his family. Dr. Tonsgard also expressed skepticism regarding the likelihood that Don would be able to find this level of care in a nursing home.

Defendant asserts that, upon turning 21 in September 2012, Don was no longer eligible to participate in the MFTDC waiver program. Don's mother avers that she was told that the home-based care program for which Don is currently eligible would provide only 20 hours per week for a personal assistant and no nursing services. I granted Plaintiff's motion for a temporary restraining order on September 18, 2012, and Don's care has thus far continued without interruption.

DISCUSSION

When considering a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, a court must treat all well-pled allegations as true, and draw all reasonable inferences in the plaintiff's favor. Justice v. Town of Cicero, 577 F.3d 768, 771 (7th Cir. 2009). "While a complaint attacked by a Rule 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss does not need detailed factual allegations, a plaintiff's obligation to provide the grounds of his entitlement to relief requires more than labels and conclusions, and a formulaic recitation of the elements of a cause of action will not do." Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544, 555 (2007). Factual allegations must be enough to raise a right to relief above the speculative level, that is, the pleading must contain something more than a statement of facts that merely creates a suspicion of a legally cognizable right of action. Id.

Plaintiff has demonstrated a claim to relief that rises beyond the speculative level. As a general matter, I find Judge Rovner's opinion in Radaszewski ex rel. Radaszewski v. Maram, 383 F.3d 599 (7th Cir. 2004), and Judge Darrah's opinion in the same case on remand to be instructive (and perhaps binding) here.

Eric Radaszewski, like Don Harris, was eligible for extensive home-based healthcare services until he reached the age of 21. Mr. Radaszewski suffers from brain cancer. A related mid-brain stroke suffered at the age of 14 left him severely impaired both physically and mentally with multiple and complex disabilities. Through the MFTDC waiver program, Mr. Radaszewski was receiving 112 hours of private-duty nursing care at home per week. The uncontradicted evidence at trial demonstrated that, given Mr. Radaszewski's fragile medical condition and his severe vulnerability to even ubiquitous and otherwise innocuous infections, this level of care was not merely desirable, but rather vital to his survival.

Like Don, Mr. Radaszewski was told that when he reached the age of 21, he would no longer qualify for the MFTDC program. He was told that, under existing state and federal programs, he would be eligible to ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.