United States District Court, Northern District of Illinois
September 18, 2012
AMERICAN COMMERCIAL LINES, LLC
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Magistrate Judge Sidney I. Schenkier
Name of Assigned Judge Rebecca R. Pallmeyer Sitting Judge if Other or Magistrate Judge than Assigned Judge Sidney I. Schenkier
DOCKET ENTRY TEXT
Settlement conference is set for 11/02/12 at 9:30 a.m. The settlement conference will be held in chambers, Rm. 1846. The settlement conference will be conducted in accordance with the Court's Standing Order on Instructions for Settlement Conference, which is enclosed and which can also be accessed from the Court's webpage at http://www.ilnd.uscourts.gov/JUDGE/ SCHENKIER/sispage.htm. The schedule for exchange of settlement letters required by the Standing Order is as follows: plaintiff's counsel shall serve a settlement letter on defense counsel by 10/08/12, and defendant's counsel shall serve a settlement letter on plaintiff's counsel by 10/25/12. The parties may not change these dates for exchange without either written agreement of the parties or court order. The plaintiff's counsel shall deliver copies of the settlement letters to chambers by noon on 10/26/12. The parties may not change this date absent court order. Parties with "full and complete settlement authority," as defined in the Standing Order, must personally attend the conference. The parties who attend the conference shall read all settlement letters prior to the commencement of the conference. Failure to comply with the Standing Order or with the schedule set in this order may result in sanctions. The status hearing set for 10/16/12 is stricken.
Notified counsel by telephone. *Copy to judge/magistrate judge.
Courtroom Deputy smk
11C2218 Moore v. American Commercial Lines, LLC Page 1 of 1
219 South Dearborn Street Chicago, IL 60604
Courtroom 1843 Telephone: (312) 435-5609 Chambers 1846 Fax Number: (312) 554-8677
INSTRUCTION FOR SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
The Court believes that the parties should fully explore and consider settlement, and should do so at the earliest reasonable opportunity in the case. For those cases that can be resolved through settlement, early consideration of settlement can allow the parties to avoid unnecessary litigation. This will allow the parties to also avoid the substantial cost, expenditure of time, and distractions that are typically a part of the litigation process. Even for those cases that cannot be resolved through settlement, early consideration of settlement can allow the parties to better understand the factual and legal nature of their dispute. This often can result in focusing and streamlining the issues to be litigated -- which again, can save the parties considerable time and money.
Consideration of settlement is a serious matter; it therefore deserves and requires serious and thorough preparation prior to the settlement conference. Set forth below are the procedures that the Court will require the parties to follow in preparing for the settlement conference, and the procedures that the Court typically will employ in conducting the conference. Counsel are directed to provide a copy of this Standing Order to their clients, and to discuss these procedures with them.
* Pre-settlement Conference Exchange of Proposals. The Court has found that settlement conferences are more likely to be productive if, before the conference, the parties have had a written exchange of their settlement positions. Accordingly, at least fourteen (14) calendar days prior to the date of the settlement conference, plaintiff's counsel shall serve on defense counsel a letter that sets forth at least the following information: (a) a brief summary of the evidence and legal principles that plaintiff asserts will allow it to establish liability, (b) a brief explanation of why damages or other relief would appropriately be granted at trial, (c) an itemization of the damages plaintiff believes can be proven at trial, and a brief summary of the evidence and legal principles supporting those damage, and (d) a settlement proposal. Defendant's counsel shall serve on plaintiff's counsel a responding letter that sets forth at least the following information: (a) any points in plaintiff's letter with which the defendant agrees,
(b) any points in plaintiff's letter with which defendant disagrees, with references to supporting evidence and legal principles, and (c) a settlement offer. The Court expects that each of these letters typically should be five pages or fewer.
* Plaintiff's counsel shall deliver copies of these letters to chambers. DO NOT FILE COPIES OF THESE LETTERS IN THE CLERK'S OFFICE.
The Order scheduling the settlement conference will set forth the dates for the exchange of letters and their delivery to chambers. The schedule is designed to ensure that the Court and the parties have enough time to prepare for the conference. Failure to comply with the schedule set by the Court may result in sanctions.
* ATTENDANCE OF PARTIES REQUIRED. Unless the Court allows otherwise by separate order, parties with full and complete settlement authority are required to personally attend the conference. This means that if a party is an individual, that individual must personally attend; if a party is a corporation or governmental entity, a representative of that corporation or governmental entity (other than counsel of record) with full and complete settlement authority must personally attend. "Full and complete settlement authority" means the authority to negotiate and agree to a binding settlement agreement at any level up to the settlement proposal of the plaintiff. If a party requires approval by an insurer to settle, then a representative of the insurer with full and complete settlement authority must attend.
The Court sets aside a significant block of time for each settlement conference. The Court strongly believes that the personal presence of the parties, and their direct participation in the discussions and "give and take" that occur, will materially increase the chances of settlement. Thus, absent a showing of unusual and extenuating circumstances, the Court will not permit a client to merely be available by telephone as an alternative to personal presence at the conference. The Court requires that parties attending the conference read the settlement letters exchanged between the parties before coming to the conference.
* CONFERENCE FORMAT. The Court generally will follow a mediation format: that is, each side will have an opportunity to make a presentation to the other side, which will be followed by joint discussion with the Court and private meetings by the Court with each side. The Court expects both the lawyers and the party representatives to be fully prepared to participate in the discussions and meetings. In these discussions, the Court expects all parties to be willing to reassess their previous positions, and to be willing to explore creative means for resolving the dispute.
* STATEMENTS INADMISSIBLE. Any statements made by any party during the settlement conference will not be admissible at trial. The Court expects the parties to address each other with courtesy and respect, but at the same time strongly encourages the parties to speak frankly and openly about their views of the case.
ANY PARTY WHO WISHES TO VARY ANY OF THE PROCEDURES SET FORTH IN THIS STANDING ORDER MUST MAKE AN APPROPRIATE REQUEST TO THE COURT PRIOR TO THE EXCHANGE OF SETTLEMENT LETTERS DESCRIBED ABOVE.
SIDNEY I. SCHENKIER United States Magistrate Judge
Dated: February 25, 2010
© 1992-2012 VersusLaw Inc.