Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

In re Gollahon

February 22, 1999

IN THE INTEREST OF BRITTANY LEE GOLLAHON AND TIFFANY DAWN GOLLAHON, MINORS, BEULAH E. WEST, PETITIONER-APPELLANT,
v.
REBECCA A. GOLLAHON, RESPONDENT-APPELLEE.



The opinion of the court was delivered by: Justice Cook

IN THE APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS FOURTH DISTRICT

Appeal from Circuit Court of Macon County

No. 97F90

Honorable Theodore E. Paine, Judge Presiding.

On September 9, 1997, Beulah West filed a petition pursuant to section 607(b) of the Illinois Marriage and Dissolution of Marriage Act (Act) seeking visitation with her two granddaughters, Tiffany and Brittany Gollahon, born August 11, 1986 (the twins). 750 ILCS 5/607(b)(1) (West 1996). Respondent Rebecca Gollahon and Beulah's son, Robert Gollahon, who died on May 13, 1997, are the twins' parents. Following a hearing, the trial court granted Beulah's petition, with visitation to occur the third Saturday of each odd-numbered month and the third Sunday of each even-numbered month from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Beulah appeals the visitation order, contending the trial court granted her an inadequate amount of visitation. We affirm.

From the time they were born, the twins visited Beulah's home almost every day while their parents worked. After the children started school, Rebecca would take them to Beulah's home before school, on her way to work. Beulah would feed and dress them, take them to school, then pick them up. The twins would stay at Beulah's after school and do homework until Rebecca got off work. Beulah also participated in the twins' school and extracurricular activities. The twins usually stayed overnight with Beulah on Wednesdays to attend church services, and on the weekends, arriving on Saturday and going back to their parents after church on Sunday. During the summer, Rebecca would take the twins to Beulah's home on a daily basis and they continued to stay there on Saturday nights.

Beulah testified that regular visitations between Beulah and the twins stopped upon Robert's death, although Beulah continued baby-sitting the twins the remaining weeks of the 1996-97 school year after Robert died. Melody, Beulah's daughter and Robert's sister, testified that within a week after Robert's death, Rebecca told her she did not want the girls to visit Beulah, that she and Beulah were no longer considered family, and that they had a new family now.

Rebecca and the twins moved in with Rebecca's boyfriend on July 9, 1997. In the seven months between Robert's death and the hearing on the petition, Beulah spent time with the twins on three occasions. Beulah testified she had been frustrated in some of her attempts to initiate telephone contact with them and that the twins "never" called her. On one occasion Rebecca's boyfriend told Beulah not to call. Melody testified that the twins told her Rebecca would not let them visit Beulah.

Tiffany and Brittany testified that during the 1997-98 school year, they went home after school, did chores, watched TV and did homework, instead of going to Beulah's. Since they stopped visiting Beulah regularly, she has telephoned them. Brittany attempted to call Beulah on one occasion but did not reach her.

According to Tiffany, Beulah said something bad about Rebecca "practically every time I [went] over there." Beulah would tell them how Rebecca's past life was bad, that Rebecca had been married so many times and "all sorts of bad things." Brittany also recalled that when she was at Beulah's, Beulah would make derogatory comments about Rebecca, that she was surprised how Rebecca's married daughter turned out as good as she did and that it was Rebecca's fault the twins' dad had been unhappy.

According to Tiffany, Rebecca and her boyfriend have told the twins that they could call or visit Beulah anytime they wanted. Tiffany recalled that they cancelled a visit with Beulah during the summer of 1997 because they preferred to stay at home to visit with Rebecca's boyfriend's child. Brittany testified that "sometimes when I want to, I will visit [Beulah], and when we get older we will want to visit her more often."

Rebecca testified that when she asks the twins, they indicate that they do not want to visit Beulah. Rebecca did not prevent the twins from visiting Beulah and they could visit her if they wanted to. Rebecca has told the twins it is their choice whether they want to visit Beulah. Rebecca also has no objection to the twins calling Beulah.

During the summer of 1997, two planned weekend visits to Beulah's were cancelled, once because the twins chose to stay at home to visit with Rebecca's boyfriend's daughter, the other because the twins chose to stay at home to visit with Rebecca's nephews. Rebecca did not know the last time the twins attended church.

In its order granting Beulah visitation, the trial court found that Beulah loves the twins and had extensive contact and a close relationship with them in the past. The trial court understood why Beulah might be upset with Rebecca, but found she has no right to control Rebecca's life and Beulah's feelings toward Rebecca have caused Beulah to inappropriately place the twins in the middle and to say things about Rebecca in the presence of the twins that have damaged the relationship between the twins and Beulah. The court concluded that Beulah had to stop the inappropriate behavior if ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.