Appeal from Circuit Court of Macon County. No. 94CF704. Honorable John L. Davis, Judge Presiding. Appeal from Circuit Court of Macon County. No. 92CF799. Honorable Scott B. Diamond, Judge Presiding.
As Modified On Denial of Rehearing December 30, 1996.
Honorable John T. McCullough, J., Honorable Robert W. Cook, P.j. - Concur, Honorable Robert J. Steigmann, J. - Concur. Justice McCULLOUGH delivered the opinion of the court.
The opinion of the court was delivered by: Mccullough
MODIFIED UPON DENIAL OF REHEARING
The Honorable Justice MCCULLOUGH delivered the opinion of the court:
In these consolidated appeals, defendant William C. Porter seeks review of sentences imposed in Macon County case Nos. 92-CF-799 and 94-CF-704. In No. 92-CF-799, defendant pleaded guilty to attempt (burglary). Ill. Rev. Stat. 1991, ch. 38, pars. 8-4(a), 19-1(a). On November 11, 1993, he was sentenced to 18 months' probation. In July and August 1994, the State filed four Petitions to revoke probation alleging (1) burglary and criminal damage to property (De Witt County case No. 94-CF-76); (2) failure to pay restitution, public defender fees, and probation service fees in Macon County case No. 92-CF-799; (3) burglary (Macon County case No. 94-CF-589); and (4) the burglary which was charged in Macon County case No. 94-CF-704. On January 4, 1995, defendant pleaded guilty to the burglary alleged in No. 94-CF-704. In what was apparently a consolidated sentencing hearing in case Nos. 92-CF-799 and 94-CF-704, defendant was sentenced to concurrent periods of probation of two years, conditioned on 90 days in jail subject to work release and 12 months' intensive probation supervision (IPS).
On October 10, 1995, a petition to revoke IPS was filed charging defendant with reckless driving while his driver's license was suspended (Macon County case Nos. 95-TR-17370, 95-TR-17371) and resisting a peace officer. On January 8, 1996, four additional petitions to revoke probations were filed alleging (1) armed robbery, home invasion, aggravated battery to a senior citizen, armed violence, and residential burglary to Wayne and Mary Campbell; (2) two counts of robbery of Ellyn and Allan Carney; (3) robbery of Dorothy Borden; and (4) attempt (armed robbery) of Jean Crane.
Following an evidentiary hearing in which evidence was presented on the petitions as to the traffic violations and resisting a peace officer, the petition as to the Campbells and the petitions as to Crane, the trial court found the allegations proved. Defendant's probations were revoked. He was sentenced to consecutive terms of imprisonment of five years in No. 92-CF-799 and seven years in No. 94-CF-704.
The only issues raised on appeal are whether (1) defendant's sentences are excessive and (2) he is entitled to 90 days' credit against his sentences for time previously served while on probation. The State responds that these issues are waived because defendant failed to file in the trial court a written post-sentencing motion challenging the correctness of the sentences. We decline to find waiver, but affirm the revocations of probations and sentences, while remanding for calculation of defendant's sentencing credit.
The first paragraph of section 5-8-1(c) of the Unified Code of Corrections (Code) now states:
"(c) A motion to reduce a sentence may be made, or the court may reduce a sentence without motion, within 30 days after the sentence is imposed. A defendant's challenge to the correctness of a sentence or to any aspect of the sentencing hearing shall be made by a written motion filed within 30 days following the imposition of sentence. However, the court may not increase a sentence once it is imposed." (Emphasis added.) 730 ILCS 5/5-8-1(c) (West 1994).
Prior to the inclusion of the emphasized language in the above quotation, the Supreme Court of Illinois interpreted the statute as being permissive and not mandatory. That is, a defendant was not required to file a written post-sentencing motion in order to preserve sentencing issues for review. People v. Lewis, 158 Ill. 2d 386, 390-91, 634 N.E.2d 717, 719-20, 199 Ill. Dec. 664 (1994). Since the amendment (Pub. Act 88-311, § 15, eff. August 11, 1993 (1993 Ill. Laws 2604, 2615)), some courts have interpreted this paragraph. People v. Cook, 279 Ill. App. 3d 718, 725-26, 665 N.E.2d 299, 303-04, 216 Ill. Dec. 239 (1995) (first district); People v. Reed, 282 Ill. App. 3d 278, 279-81, 668 N.E.2d 51, 52-54, 217 Ill. Dec. 866 (1996) (first district); People v. O'Neal, 281 Ill. App. 3d 602, 612-13, 667 N.E.2d 516, 523, 217 Ill. Dec. 427 (1996) (first district); People v. McCleary, 278 Ill. App. 3d 498, 501-02, 663 N.E.2d 22, 24-25, 215 Ill. Dec. 272 (1996) (first district); People v. Moncrief, 276 Ill. App. 3d 533, 535, 659 N.E.2d 106, 108, 213 Ill. Dec. 476 (1995) (second district). McCleary and Cook were both decided by the first district, first division.
Recognizing that the legislature retained the word "may" in the first sentence of section 5-8-1(c), we agree with the interpretation placed on it by Cook. The statute, even as amended, does not require a defendant to file a post-sentencing motion as a prerequisite to an appeal. It merely dictates the form it must take and when it must be filed if defendant chooses to file one. In addition, this interpretation avoids any possible challenge to the constitutionality of this section based on the separation of powers clause of the Illinois Constitution. Ill. Const. 1970, art. II, § 1.
The first issue is whether the sentence was excessive. Defendant's entire argument is that his character and potential for rehabilitation are such that lesser sentences would be appropriate. Defendant, born July 16, 1975, points to a criminal history in the presentence investigation report (PSI) that includes a juvenile adjudication for burglary and criminal damage to property less than $300 (Macon County case No. 91-J-62) and two speeding tickets as an adult (Macon County case No. 92-TR-2152; Edgar County case No. 94-TR-595). He admits there is also a conviction for reckless driving and driving while his driver's license was suspended (Macon ...