Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

12/21/88 Michael Glenville, v. Police Board of the City

December 21, 1988





532 N.E.2d 490, 177 Ill. App. 3d 583, 126 Ill. Dec. 805 1988.IL.1852

Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook County; the Hon. Albert Green, Judge, presiding.


JUSTICE McNAMARA delivered the opinion of the court. WHITE, P.J., and RIZZI, J., concur.


Petitioner, Michael Glenville, appeals from the decision of the circuit court of Cook County upholding the findings and discharge order of the respondent, the Police Board of the City of Chicago (Board). Glenville contends the trial court improperly refused to review the Board's failure to consider his alcoholism as a mitigating factor when determining an appropriate sanction for his misconduct.

Glenville does not contest the Board's findings that he disobeyed general departmental rules and regulations and thereby brought discredit upon the police department. Glenville questions, however, the failure of the Board to find his alcoholism to be a mitigating factor and to temper its sanction accordingly.

Glenville's discharge stemmed from a series of undisputed events which occurred on March 28, 1984. The following facts were presented in testimony before the Board. At approximately 2 a.m., Brenda Yearby and Rufus Terry were at the Snuggery, a lounge in Chicago. Yearby had with her a briefcase containing $1,140, mostly in $1 bills but arranged with some larger bills on top. Yearby and Terry displayed the money to the doorman at the Snuggery and proceeded to the bar. She and Terry ordered drinks and then they danced for some time with the briefcase nearby. Glenville also was at the Snuggery that morning. By the time Yearby and Terry arrived, he had consumed several alcoholic drinks. Glenville approached the couple and tried to take the briefcase but Yearby stopped him. Yearby and Terry left shortly after this incident and went to Yearby's room at the Paxton Hotel. Sergeant Michael Williamson testified that he saw Glenville and another man follow the couple outside the Snuggery but did not see where Glenville went after that. Yearby testified that a blue and white police car followed them to the Paxton.

Approximately one-half hour after Yearby and Terry arrived at the Paxton, Glenville and another man entered the hotel lobby. Glenville asked the doorman, Charles Carner, where Yearby and Terry had gone. Glenville identified himself as a police officer and showed Carner his star. He demanded the passkey to Yearby's room but Carner refused to release the key. At this point, a third man entered the building. Glenville proceeded behind the desk and attempted to take the key from Carner by force. He produced a gun and held it to Carner's head, threatening to blow Carner's head off if he did not turn over the key. Glenville beat and kicked Carner for 5 to 10 minutes, at which point Carner relented and agreed to take Glenville upstairs. The second man followed Glenville and Carner upstairs while the third man remained in the lobby.

Inside her room, Yearby heard shouting and two gunshots in the hall. She awakened Terry and hid him in the closet. She placed the briefcase full of money under her dresser. The door to her room opened and Carner, Glenville and the other man entered. Carner immediately dove under Yearby's bed. Glenville placed the gun against Yearby's head and asked where Terry was. Yearby pointed to the closet and Glenville ordered the second man to remove Terry from the closet. Glenville took Terry by the neck, banged his head against the wall several times, and demanded the briefcase. Glenville then ordered Yearby to open the briefcase for him. He was unable to stuff the money into his shirt, so he placed the money back into the briefcase and stated he would take the briefcase and its contents. Glenville then pulled Carner from under the bed and dragged him from the room.

In the hall, Glenville encountered Jeffrey Catchings. Glenville grabbed Catchings and demanded to know what he was doing in the hall. Glenville took his gun out, aimed it at Catchings and began to push Catchings into a nearby room. He started to follow Catchings inside but stopped when the second man called to him. Glenville and the two other men left the hotel and drove off in a new model blue car. Carner called the police.

Sergeant Williamson responded to the call. He recognized Yearby and Terry as the couple he had seen leaving the Snuggery followed by Glenville. Williamson searched the neighborhood and apprehended Glenville and the two other men as they attempted to drive off in a light blue automobile. Williamson called for back-up officers. The officers searched the suspects and recovered approximately $1,000, mostly in $1 bills. Williamson also recovered from Glenville a police star and identification card, an empty holster, and a handgun with two burn marks indicating that it recently had been fired. The handgun was not registered to Glenville. Glenville was arrested.

Glenville was charged with armed robbery, armed violence, residential burglary, home invasion, and felony theft. After his release on bail he was admitted to a chemical dependency program for detoxification and treatment. While there, he began to attend Alcoholics Anonymous meetings. He presently attends such meetings approximately three times per week. At his criminal trial, however, he testified that he was not an alcoholic and that at the time of the crime he had no alcoholic problems. He was found guilty of misdemeanor theft and was sentenced to one year of conditional discharge.

The Chicago police department charged Glenville with violations of several departmental rules. An administrative hearing before the Board was held on December 5, 1985. Glenville did not contest the charges, but testified that he could not recall the events because he committed the crimes during a "blackout" caused by overconsumption of alcohol. He presented evidence that ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.