APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS, FIRST DISTRICT, FIFTH DIVISION
531 N.E.2d 966, 176 Ill. App. 3d 900, 126 Ill. Dec. 339 1988.IL.1708
Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook County; the Hon. Christy Berkos, Judge, presiding.
JUSTICE MURRAY delivered the opinion of the court. LORENZ, P.J., and PINCHAM, J., concur.
DECISION OF THE COURT DELIVERED BY THE HONORABLE JUDGE MURRAY
This is a consolidated appeal by defendants, William Connor and Roderick Bulls, from a bench trial in which they were found guilty of delivery of more than 30 grams of a controlled substance. They each were subsequently sentenced to six years of imprisonment. The trial court directed verdicts for defendants on the charges of calculated criminal drug conspiracy. Two other defendants, Randy Tapley and Leotes Tillie, were acquitted on the same two counts.
The record discloses the following facts: In October 1983, Bulls was 30 years old and married with five children. His cousin, Connor, was the same age and unmarried, although by trial time he had married a woman with three children. Both defendants attended college: Connor received a degree from Tuskegee Institute and Bulls was nine hours short of receiving a degree in business administration from the University of Southern Colorado. Neither man had any previous criminal record nor any known involvement as users or sellers of drugs.
In the fall of 1983, Bulls began his own business as a shipping broker, having previously worked as a broker for Universal Air Freight. Connor worked as a full-time assistant coach and security aid for the Waukegan School District. He also worked part time as a salesman for a men's clothing store and as an account executive for Bulls' business. As a shipping broker, Bulls would find truckers to transport goods for various suppliers. This necessitated that Bulls issue "comp" checks to the drivers immediately after or during their trips to cover their expenses. Bulls testified that a shipper was responsible to Bulls for that amount immediately after delivery of the goods, with the remainder owed to him due between 7 and 30 days thereafter.
On at least four occasions prior to December 29, Bulls had shipped goods for shippers, such as Pepperidge Farm, obtained by a man he knew as Bobby Johnson . B.J. claimed to be a representative for Donna Produce, which allegedly was owned by B.J.'s wife. Bulls obtained transportation for these shipments through Seacoast Shippers. He would front the comp money to the drivers, after which he did not receive reimbursement from B.J. Seacoast then billed Bulls for the shipments. Documents submitted by Bulls showed that Donna Produce owed him over $13,000, which was never paid despite Bulls' repeated requests to B.J. for payment. According to Bulls, he was therefore unable to pay Seacoast and could not book any new business. Additionally, accounts he had obtained on his own with companies such as McDonald's and Dean Foods were jeopardized because consistency and reliability were critical factors in this kind of business.
On December 29, 1983, B.J. called Bulls and said he had a $2,700 comp check for him and asked Bulls to meet him at a Red Coach Inn restaurant (Red Coach) in Schiller Park. When Bulls arrived, B.J. introduced him to another man, Mike Kennedy, who claimed to work for Donna Produce and supposedly had five trucks and drivers. In reality, Kennedy was Gary Brotan, a Cook County sheriff's police officer assigned to Northeastern Metropolitan Enforcement Group as an undercover agent. When Bulls asked for the comp check, B.J. said he had not yet received it but that it was in the mail to him . After discussing trucking business, Brotan and B.J. told Bulls that they supplied cocaine to truckers, but that Brotan's source was under arrest. They asked Bulls if he could obtain some cocaine. Later, after B.J. and Bulls returned from the washroom, a small packet of white powder, later determined to be cocaine, was passed to Brotan at the bar. Bulls testified that in the washroom, B.J. had showed the packet to him and said that Bulls was supposed to have brought it for Brotan. Bulls denied giving it to Brotan; Brotan was not sure from whom he had received the packet, Bulls or B.J.
After this meeting, Bulls testified that he kept asking B.J. for the money owed him and was told that "Kennedy" needed a new source. Bulls claimed that he knew of no source. Bulls said that eventually B.J. told him that if he (Bulls) could find a source, B.J. would then be able to pay him. On December 30, Brotan called Bulls and again asked if Bulls could obtain cocaine. Bulls handed the phone to Leo. At trial, Brotan made a voice identification of Leo as Leotes Tillie, which identification was objected to by defendants. When asked to sell Brotan a half ounce of cocaine, Leo responded by saying that he (Leo) had to contact someone else. Brotan called later and Leo said his source was out of town. On January 1, 1984, Brotan again called Bulls and Bulls said he would have to contact Leo.
Meanwhile, Bulls had asked his cousin Connor to help. After several more phone calls from Brotan, Bulls called him back on January 2, telling him to meet Leo at the Red Coach. No one but Brotan went to the meeting place. Brotan then called Bulls, and Leo arranged to meet him that night (January 3) along with Bulls and Connor. By that time, Connor had found a source, Ambrosia Chapa. Connor testified that Chapa was in the clothing store and overheard Connor talking to Bulls on the telephone. Chapa, who had previously worked in the store, offered to help Connor.
Bulls, Connor, and Brotan met on January 3. Brotan asked Connor if he could handle two kilos of cocaine and Connor replied that he would have to talk to his source. After making several telephone calls, Connor told Brotan that he could supply it, but details had to be worked out later because the source was too high to deal at that time. Bulls then told Brotan that he had a half ounce to sell for $1,000, but Brotan replied that he did not need it if he could get two kilos. Brotan took a sample from the ounce supply. The next day, there were several more calls between Brotan, Connor, and Bulls to work out details. Connor set up a meeting for the next evening (January 5) in Bulls' business office in Waukegan. Brotan vetoed that location and suggested the Bob Evans restaurant in Des Plaines.
On January 5, Brotan called Bulls, who told him that Connor would be calling. Connor called Brotan later and said that his source was still looking for some cocaine. The meeting was later cancelled because Connor could not reach the source. There were many more calls on January 6. Brotan was told that the source didn't like the quality of the drug and was still searching. On January 7, B.J. told Bulls that he would have a $2,700 comp check for him which B.J. would bring to the meeting at Bob Evans later that day. Later, Connor, Bulls, and Leo went to the restaurant as did Chapa, Brotan, and Randy ...