APPEAL from the Circuit Court of Cook County; the Hon. JAMES
M. BAILEY, Judge, presiding.
MR. JUSTICE O'CONNOR DELIVERED THE OPINION OF THE COURT:
Defendant, Larry Jackson, was found guilty by a jury of three counts of armed robbery and was sentenced to six to twenty years. Defendant appeals.
Clarence Lester, one of the complaining witnesses, testified that on September 18, 1976, at approximately 1 a.m., he was at a lounge located at 68th and Green Streets in Chicago. Johnnie Mae Drain, a woman acquainted with some people who knew him, asked him to come outside and look at her car, which had just been in an accident. Lester then went with Johnnie Mae and her cousin, Antine Drain, and looked at Johnnie Mae's car. Afterwards, he and the Drains walked back on 68th Street towards the lounge. Near Green Street, two men came up behind them and said, "don't turn around, this is a stickup." Lester testified that he and the Drains did turn around. He identified defendant and Jerry Wells as having been the assailants and further stated that Wells at that time appeared to be holding a gun.
Johnnie Mae Drain testified that one of the assailants had a gun. She further stated that although she had concentrated most of her attention on the gun, she was positive defendant was the other assailant. She testified that she knew defendant, because the year prior to the incident defendant had lived a block away from her and she had talked with him before and had seen him when she visited her girlfriend's house.
Lester testified that after he and the Drains were informed it was a "stickup," Jerry Wells told them to throw their money on the ground and also ordered Johnnie Mae to throw her purse down and Antine to remove his jacket. They threw these items on the ground, Lester testified, and Johnnie Mae said, "Larry, you know me. * * * Why do you want to do this?" Lester asked Wells if he could pick up his car keys, which he had accidentally thrown on the ground with his change, and Wells told him he could. As he was reaching for the keys, he heard what sounded like a gunshot being fired. Lester was not hit by the shot, but Johnnie Mae testified that when Lester reached for the keys Wells was holding the gun "dead at" him and then fired it. She saw fire come from the gun and thought Lester had been shot.
Johnnie Mae Drain further testified that after the shot was fired, she ran back to the lounge and told someone there to call the police. Lester stated that he also ran a few steps, then turned around and saw defendant and Wells run a short distance south into an alley on Green Street and enter a corner apartment building facing 68th Street. He observed defendant and Wells running upstairs in a crouched position before they were out of view.
Several minutes after the gun was fired, the police arrived. Lester told them the offenders had run into a corner building at 68th and Green Streets, and Johnnie Mae Drain, Lester, Antine Drain and the police then entered the building and went up to the second floor. The police knocked on an apartment door and they were all admitted into the apartment. A number of people were inside having a party. Johnnie Mae Drain and Lester both testified that shortly afterwards they observed defendant hiding under a bed in a rear bedroom of the apartment. Lester stated that the rear bedroom was well lighted.
The police took defendant downstairs and outside. When they came outside, Lester testified, they were joined by another policeman who had apprehended Jerry Wells. Lester testified that he identified Wells to the policemen as the other offender and that Wells had money in his mouth. Johnnie Mae Drain stated that the police then left with Wells and defendant, and she, Antine and Lester followed them in her car to the police station. Lester and Johnnie Mae Drain further testified they did not see the latter's purse at any time after it was taken.
Officer Charles Bowers testified that at approximately 1 a.m. on September 18, 1976, he and his partner, Officer Larry Hargrove, arrived at 68th and Green Streets in response to a call that a man had been shot. There he saw Lester and Johnnie Mae and Antine Drain, who told him they had been held up by two black males, who had run into a building down the street. He, his partner, Lester and the Drains then entered the building. They went up to the second floor, where they heard noises coming from an apartment. They knocked on the apartment door and someone let them in and allowed them to search for the offenders. About 10 or 15 people were in the apartment. Lester and the Drains told him they did not recognize any of them. He and his partner, with Lester and the Drains, then went through a hallway and entered a rear bedroom of the apartment. There they noticed defendant hiding under the bed and he ordered defendant to come out with his hands up.
When defendant crawled out from under the bed, Officer Bowers testified, Lester and the Drains said, "[T]hat's the man, that's the man." Officer Hargrove also testified that when defendant came out from under the bed Lester and the Drains "automatically pointed to [defendant] and stated he was the one." Officer Bowers further testified that he and Officer Hargrove did not search the apartment except for the rear bedroom and that they recovered some money from defendant, but did not recover a purse or jacket.
Larry Butler testified as a defense witness. He stated he was also known as Jerry Wells and that he had been convicted and was serving time in the penitentiary for participating in the crime with which defendant was charged. Butler further testified that on September 18, 1976, at about 1 a.m., he and Vincent Adams approached two men and a woman on the corner of 68th and Green Streets and told them it was a "stickup" and not to turn around. They turned around anyway and he told them to empty their pockets, which they did. One of the men, Butler stated, then asked if he could pick up his car keys and Butler told him he could. As the man bent down for the keys, he reached for Butler's leg as though he intended to trip him, so Butler fired a shot at him. Butler testified that Adams then took the woman's purse and he and Adams ran down 68th Street, through an alley to a vacant lot, where they divided the money in the purse. They left the purse there and walked up on a back porch behind an apartment building on 68th Street. About five or 10 minutes later, a policeman came down the alley. Adams ran down the stairs past the policeman, Butler testified. He himself ducked behind a garbage can, threw his gun on the roof of the porch and put the money in his mouth. The police officer then arrested him and brought him around to the front of the apartment building, where he saw defendant for the first time that evening. Butler testified that defendant had nothing to do with the planning of the robbery and was not anywhere in the area when the robbery occurred that he knew of.
Butler further testified that he had known Vincent Adams since 1975 and that at the time of defendant's trial Adams was 15 or 16 years old, five feet eight or nine inches tall, and weighed 145 pounds. Also, Butler stated that when he was arrested he told the arresting officer that he had committed the crime with Vincent Adams. At another point in his testimony, Butler stated he did not tell the arresting officer that Vincent Adams was the person with whom he had committed the crime.
Butler also testified that he knew defendant under the names of both Larry Jackson and Larry Williams. He had known defendant since about 1971 or 1972; defendant lived upstairs in the same building Butler lived in. Butler further testified that he had been in contact with defendant since the crime. Defendant had written him a letter from county jail; after Butler received the letter, he had discussed his testimony in this case with defendant.
Defendant testified that on September 18, 1976, at approximately 1 a.m., he did not rob Johnnie Mae Drain or anyone else on 68th and Green Streets. Defendant asserted that at that time he was in his associate's second floor apartment at 843 West 68th Street, and had been there since about 9 p.m., listening to music, gambling and smoking marijuana. Defendant stated that about 30 other people were in the apartment and that he knew them from the ...