APPEAL from the Circuit Court of Cook County; the Hon. ARTHUR
L. DUNNE, Judge, presiding.
MR. PRESIDING JUSTICE JOHNSON DELIVERED THE OPINION OF THE COURT:
This action was brought by the owner and contract purchaser of a tract of land for a declaratory judgment that the Northbrook zoning ordinance and the conditions and restrictions of the R-3 single-family residence classification are unconstitutional as applied to the subject tract, and that the plaintiffs have a right to implement their proposed development of the property as a neighborhood shopping center within the B-2 classification under said ordinance. The court, sitting without a jury, ruled the R-3 single-family residence classification, as applied to the subject property, is unconstitutional and void. The court further denied the plaintiffs' prayer that they be permitted to develop the property as proposed. Bruce M. Pillman (hereinafter plaintiff) takes this appeal only from the denial of his proposed use. The Village of Northbrook (hereinafter the Village), as cross-appellant, has taken an appeal from the ruling voiding the single-family residence classification while leaving the subject property unzoned. This cross-appeal was withdrawn, however, by the Village during oral argument.
The sole issue presented for review, after withdrawal of the cross-appeal, is whether the trial court erred in prohibiting the plaintiff from developing the subject property as proposed.
Plaintiff Pillman is the contract owner of a tract of real estate located at the northwest corner of Dundee and Greenwood Roads, in the Village of Northbrook, Illinois. The subject property has at all times been classified within the R-3 single-family residence classification as prescribed by the zoning ordinance of the Village since its annexation by the Village.
On or about January 19, 1973, plaintiff applied to the Village for an amendment to the Village's zoning ordinance, and the application was denied.
On July 5, 1973, plaintiff filed a complaint for declaratory judgment, alleging that the denial of his application by the Village is unconstitutional, and asking for a finding that plaintiff has the right to use the subject premises in accordance with his said application before the Village. The Village filed its answer, generally denying the allegations of the complaint and raising no affirmative defenses. The cause proceeded to trial.
The subject property is a vacant rectangular-shaped parcel located on the northwest corner of Dundee and Greenwood Roads, having a frontage of 264 feet along Dundee Road and 247 feet along Greenwood. Along the north line of the property is a tree line and shrubbery. The property comprises an area of 64,000 square feet, or 1 1/2 acres.
Directly to the north of the subject property is a subdivision of approximately 30 single-family homes fronting on Greenwood Road. Greenwood Road is located directly east of and adjacent to the subject property. It runs north approximately 1 block and dead-ends at a barbed wire fence at that point.
Directly to the south of and adjacent to the subject site is Dundee Road, a four-lane divided state highway running east and west. Along the south line of Dundee Road and running both east and west of the subject site is a tree line consisting of trees 30 to 40 feet in height and a 6-foot-high fence. Due south thereof is the Northbrook Knolls Subdivision, which is a single-family residential subdivision.
To the immediate west of and adjacent to the subject site is the shopping center owned by plaintiff, improved with buildings in a Z-shaped configuration and extending approximately 400 feet west from the west line of the subject property along the north side of Dundee Road. The center consists of a number of commercial tenants. The largest area occupied by any tenant is about 3200 square feet. Tenants include a retail pharmacy, a delicatessen, beauty and barber shops, dry cleaning establishments, liquor and food stores, realty office, outdoor sports shop, fabric shop, and a fully enclosed medical complex.
Immediately to the west of and adjacent to the shopping center, extending about 100 feet westerly, is a hardware store. Directly to the west of and adjacent to the hardware store and extending about 100 feet along the north line of Dundee Road to the east line of Pfingsten Road is a Shell service and gasoline station, situated on the northeast corner of Dundee and Pfingsten Roads. On the northwest corner of Dundee and Pfingsten is a Citgo service station. Directly north and west thereof is the Cambridge Court Apartment complex which consists of about 50 units, and to the immediate north and west thereof is a single-family subdivision known as Sky Harbor Subdivision.
At the southeast corner of Dundee and Pfingsten is a Gulf or "E-Z-Go" gasoline service station, and at the southwest corner is a land sales office.
In accordance with his application to the Village, plaintiff's proposed plan calls for an L-shaped building of about 17,800 square feet of area, which would be within the prescriptions of the B-2 commercial classification of the Northbrook zoning ordinance.
The court heard expert testimony of land planners, appraisers, traffic analysts, and engineers before finding the existing classification unconstitutional, yet prohibiting plaintiffs Pillman and Willi from developing the subject ...