Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Schroeder v. Busenhart

MARCH 10, 1967.

GERALD A. SCHROEDER, ET AL., PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS AND CROSS-APPELLEES,

v.

J.C. BUSENHART, ET AL., DEFENDANTS-APPELLEES AND CROSS-APPELLANTS.



Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook County; the Hon. EDWARD SCHULTZ, Judge, presiding. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded with directions.

MR. PRESIDING JUSTICE ENGLISH DELIVERED THE OPINION OF THE COURT.

Rehearing denied April 14, 1967.

This appeal is from a summary judgment in favor of some fifty defendants alleged in the complaint to have participated in an unlawful conspiracy to deprive plaintiffs of their fruit and vegetable business which had been conducted on plaintiffs' land before it was taken for school purposes through condemnation proceedings. The complaint also alleged separate wrongful acts by individual defendants, and, as to these allegations, the complaint was dismissed without prejudice to plaintiffs' right to institute separate suits against the individual defendants. Defendants have filed a cross appeal from that portion of the order which denied their motion to tax against plaintiffs certain of defendants' expenses and attorney's fees.

On November 6, 1959, proceedings were brought by Township School Trustees to have the land of the Schroeders (plaintiffs in the instant case) condemned for the use and benefit of School District No. 57, Cook County, Illinois. The Schroeders filed a traverse, which, as amended, denied that the School District intended to take the property for public purposes. After the traverse was overruled, the case was tried before a jury which returned a verdict awarding the Schroeders $267,083.33. A motion for a new trial by the School Trustees was granted. On appeal by the Schroeders, the Supreme Court reversed and remanded with directions to enter judgment on the verdict, but refused to review the ruling on the traverse. Trustees of Schools of Township No. 42, Board of Education of School Dist. No. 57, Cook County v. Schroeder, 23 Ill.2d 74, 177 N.E.2d 178. Pursuant to this mandate the Circuit Court set aside its order granting a new trial, and entered judgment for the amount of the verdict and costs. On October 23, 1961, an order was entered finding that the judgment award had been satisfied by payment to the County Treasurer for the benefit of the Schroeders, and that the School Trustees had thereupon become vested with the fee simple title to the land and the right to enter thereon and take possession. Pursuant to another order of the Circuit Court directed to the Sheriff, the Schroeders and most of their personal property were removed from the condemned premises and the School Trustees were put in possession of the property on December 13, 1961. The Schroeders appealed from the order vesting title to the property in the School Trustees on the ground that the particular school district involved could not take land by eminent domain within 40 rods of the owners' dwelling. This appeal was also decided adversely to the Schroeders. Trustees of Schools of Township No. 42, Board of Education of School Dist. No. 57, Cook County v. Schroeder, 25 Ill.2d 289, 184 N.E.2d 872.

Immediately following the decision in this second appeal, the Schroeders obtained new counsel, who filed motions in the Supreme Court for leave to file their additional appearances on behalf of the Schroeders, for leave to file an additional petition for rehearing, and for an order restraining any construction on the property. These motions were all denied by the Supreme Court on September 12, 1962.

Meanwhile, the Schroeders themselves were not idle. They allegedly reentered the premises and took possession of the condemned property during the 1962 Labor Day weekend. The School Trustees, on September 4, 1962, filed a petition for a supplemental writ of possession to remove the Schroeders and to restrain them from further interfering with the rightful possession of the School Trustees. The answer of the Schroeders to this petition denied that the Schroeders had retaken possession of the property, and further charged:

4. These Respondents further say that there is great and intense feeling against the graft, corruption and debauchery as shown by the attempted taking of this large tract of land for just an elementary school, the large contractors [sic] entered into and the eagerness and avidity with which the consummation of contracts is sought, the People of Mt. Prospect are up in arms against this project and are going to great lengths because they do not wish to see their tax monies dissipated with the result that things are done and Respondents blamed therefor.

The above charge was stricken as scurrilous by the Circuit Court on its own motion. An Assistant State's Attorney investigating the charge interviewed the Schroeders and Alfred Loeser, one of their new attorneys, and reported to the court that the Schroeders had no foundation for the charge.

The Schroeders' new counsel also filed several other documents in the Circuit Court. On August 16, 1962, they filed a paper charging that the School Trustees had abandoned their petition to condemn because the compensation required to be paid by the original judgment order entered October 27, 1960, was not paid within 150 days of the entry of that order. In addition, a motion was filed charging that there were several defects in the condemnation proceedings and seeking to restrain the School Trustees from dealing with the condemned property. On September 25, 1962, the Schroeders filed another petition in the Circuit Court in which they charged that the court had no authority to enter an order evicting them from the property and no authority to vest title in the School Trustees.

On October 4, 1962, the Circuit Court granted the order prayed for in the September 4, 1962, petition of the School Trustees, and denied the various motions and petitions of the Schroeders. The Schroeders thereupon filed notice of appeal and on November 2, 1962, again requested the Circuit Court to restrain the School Trustees from dealing with the condemned land until after the decision of the new appeal to the Supreme Court. This petition was denied by the Circuit Court.

In a wholly separate action commenced prior to the denial of the petition for rehearing on the second appeal, the new counsel for the Schroeders, on their behalf and on behalf of various other alleged taxpayers in the School District, filed a petition in the Circuit Court (under Ill Rev Stats 1961, c 102, §§ 11-16) for leave to file a taxpayers' complaint to enjoin the Board of Education from expending public funds for construction of a school on the condemned property. Leave to file this taxpayers' complaint was denied by the Circuit Court, and the Schroeders again appealed.

The Supreme Court, over objection of the Schroeders, consolidated these two last-mentioned appeals and again ruled against the Schroeders' contentions. Matters raised in regard to the condemnation suit were held to have been conclusively adjudicated in an earlier appeal, while some of the matters raised in the taxpayers' complaint were held to have been improperly pleaded because they constituted a collateral attack on a final judgment. Other matters raised in the taxpayers' complaint were said to be conclusions of the pleader or of too indefinite a nature to constitute reasonable grounds upon which to predicate a taxpayers' suit. Both rulings of the Circuit Court were therefore affirmed in an opinion filed September 27, 1963. People ex rel. White v. Busenhart, 29 Ill.2d 156, 193 N.E.2d 850.

The Schroeders next instituted suit in the United States District Court on January 20, 1964, against the School Trustees and the Board of Education, among others, in which they sought to have the various proceedings, judgments and orders of the Illinois courts declared null and void. The complaint was dismissed with prejudice for want of jurisdiction, and the Court of Appeals affirmed on the ground that the suit was nothing more than an improper collateral attack on a valid judgment. Schroeder v. Illinois, 354 F.2d 561 (7th Cir, 1965). Petition of the Schroeders for certiorari was denied (384 U.S. 972).

Shortly before the Federal Court action was filed, the instant suit was commenced on December 11, 1963, generally charging a conspiracy and, in addition, charging numerous wrongful acts against various individual defendants. The conspiracy count charges that some fifty defendants, including certain School Trustees and Sheriff's deputies, on or about December 12, 1961, ". . . conspired together and formed deliberate design and purpose to ruin, oppress and impoverish these Plaintiffs and to destroy and damage their business also." The complaint states that plaintiffs were the owners of the property in question on December 12, 1961, at which time the ...


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.