Searching over 5,500,000 cases.

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

The People v. Porter





WRIT OF ERROR to the Criminal Court of Cook County; the Hon. JULIUS J. HOFFMAN, Judge, presiding.


This cause was heard upon a writ of error to the criminal court of Cook County to review a judgment entered on a jury verdict finding defendant, Augustine Porter, guilty of murder and imposing a 50-year penitentiary sentence. Whether or not the evidence adduced by the prosecution was sufficient to sustain a guilty verdict, alleged errors in the admission of evidence, and the propriety of the trial court in giving and refusing certain instructions are the only issues presented for our determination. It is claimed by defendant that the unquestioned circumstances surrounding the killing establish a homicide that was excusable in that it stemmed from misadventure.

The alleged murder with which defendant is charged occurred on January 1, 1948. According to defendant's testimony, it appears that Maggie Pry, the deceased, and defendant had lived together for over a year as common-law man and wife, during which time he paid her about $20 a week. This illicit cohabitation discontinued in September, 1947, for it was at that time that the landlady ordered defendant from the premises. Defendant claims Maggie Pry had telephoned him at 3:00 P.M. on January 1, 1948, to call for some of his clothes. At about 4:35 P.M. defendant was admitted to the building by one of the tenants, when he rang the doorbell to the outside entrance of the basement, and he went to Maggie Pry's apartment.

Defendant knocked on the door of the apartment several times, and she asked, "Who is it?" When he replied, "It is Porter," she said, "Wait a minute." He waited 20 minutes and knocked again, whereupon, according to defendant's testimony, Maggie Pry called out, "He won't let me open the door. You push the door. It's not locked." He pushed the door and tore it from the facing, and entered the apartment, which consisted of an 8' x 10' room in which there was a bed, refrigerator, stove, table, chest and chair. J.C. Cook, a witness, was seated beside Maggie Pry on the bed. They both jumped up, and Maggie Pry said, "Don't start nothing." Defendant claims he said, "I am coming for my things," and the man said, "I'll take care of this," and started toward him with his hand in his pocket. Whereupon defendant pulled out his pocket knife, which was open in his pocket, and, as he struck at the man, Maggie Pry ran between them and was stabbed.

Defendant further testified that he did not intend to stab her; that she told him to get out before he got hurt; that a neighbor, L.C. April, told him that Cook had a gun; and he fled from the building. Defendant claimed he was frightened and went to a movie, where he remained until about 8 P.M. When he arrived home, his mother told him the police had been there, and asked what had happened. He gave her this same account, and she informed him for the first time that Maggie Pry was dead. He then called the police, and made a statement at the station, which was taken down on a typewriter by one of the officers on duty.

Defendant's testimony, however, was impeached by his original voluntary statement to the police. He made no reference to Maggie Pry's telephoning him to come over, and said that when he originally knocked on the door and identified himself, Maggie Pry asked, "What do you want?" When he told her he wanted his underwear, she told him he could not have it. He also stated that he had his knife open when he forced open the door and broke the facing; that Cook and Maggie Pry both jumped up from the bed; that Maggie Pry said, "Now don't start nothing," and caught the thrust of the knife intended for Cook. Maggie Pry then screamed for L.C. April, who told defendant that Cook had a gun. Defendant made no reference to Cook having his hand in his pocket when defendant entered the room.

Louis April, a neighbor of the deceased, testified for the State that he had seen deceased earlier in the day on January 1, 1948; that he heard defendant knock on the door of Maggie Pry's apartment; that he heard Maggie Pry say, "Who is it? Wait a minute"; that he looked out in the hall and saw Porter there; that Porter knocked 20 minutes later, and Maggie called out, "You can't come in now"; that he heard the crashing of the door, which was followed some seconds later by a scream, "L.C., Porter stabbed me." Maggie Pry then came to his room, bleeding from the chest, and then staggered down the hall to the telephone, where she collapsed. She lay in the hallway until the police officer came and took her to the hospital, where she was pronounced dead. The witness further testified that he did not see Porter either enter or leave the apartment, but saw Cook in the hallway after the stabbing.

The landlady testified that the door was torn from its facing when she arrived at the apartment at 5 P.M. The tenant who admitted Porter to the building testified accordingly, and another neighbor testified to hearing the crash of the door and the scream, but she did not pay too much attention or leave her apartment because Maggie Pry and Porter often fought. When she heard the noise in the hall, she walked out to find Maggie Pry stretched out on the floor, with blood running down her side.

J.C. Cook denied being in the apartment at the time Porter pushed open the door. He testified that he had come to Maggie's apartment looking for his sister, who had formerly been Maggie's roommate; that as he entered into the hallway he saw Porter standing at Maggie's door with a knife in his hand; and later, while he was still in the hall, he heard Maggie cry out, "Porter stabbed me." He testified further that he called the police after Maggie fell in the hallway near the telephone. He did not, however, give a statement to the police until several days later. Nor did he testify at the inquest.

Several witnesses testified to defendant's good character and reputation as a law-abiding citizen.

The officer who took down defendant's statement with reference to the homicide testified that defendant did not tell him that Maggie had telephoned asking him to come over; nor that she said, "The gentlemen will not let me open the door. It's not locked. Push it open"; nor that J.C. Cook attempted to assault him, or had his hand in his pocket when defendant entered the room; nor that Maggie Pry said, "Porter, you'd better get out." The officer admitted that he had testified from his recollection, at the coroner's inquest, as to a struggle between defendant, Cook, and the deceased, but that defendant had never told him of any fights, or blows, or assaults from Cook.

On the basis of substantially the foregoing evidence, defendant's motion for a directed verdict was overruled. The court gave some 28 instructions on behalf of the State, and some 9 instructions on behalf of defendant. The jury found defendant guilty of murder as charged, and ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.